When Pius Walder from East Tyrol was shot while poaching in 1982, the courts ruled intentional bodily harm with a fatal outcome. But in the village of Villgraten, the circumstances surrounding Pius’ death continue to divide the resident families to this day. What really happened on that day? How did the judge reach his verdict? And why did Pius’ brothers swear revenge and haven’t forgiven to this day? The fantastical stories surrounding the Walder boys have led many media outlets to stylise them as “Alpine Robin Hoods”. This film goes in search of the facts of this contentious case.